Progress in Cardiovascular Surgery
January 21, 1999
Gerald Lawrie, founding partner of Texas Surgical Associates and clinical
professor at Baylor College of Medicine, has completed more than 300 consecutive
mitral valve repairs during the past 15 years with record success, especially
when compared to statistics for valve replacements. In doing so, he now often
uses minimally invasive techniques-like keyhole surgery-that provide
greater patient comfort and faster recuperation than the more traditional
chest-sawing procedures.
In a recently published study of his first 200 patients, Lawrie shows that mitral
valve repair significantly reduces mortality rates when compared to mitral valve
replacements. Hospital mortality rates for mitral valve repair were only 1 to
3%, compared to 3 to 15% for replacements.
"Patients are benefiting from the variety of techniques which allow us to repair
valves more successfully than replace them," Lawrie says. "When coupled with
minimally invasive surgery, this is the way of the future for cardiovascular
surgery. The exciting news is that we're already doing it routinely today in the
Texas Medical Center. Patients don't have to leave Houston for this surgery."
Lawrie studied patients with a mean age of 62.5, plus or minus 14.7 years. Of
the 200 patients, 103 were men, 17% previously had cardiac surgery, and 19.9% had
additional cardiac procedures, such as coronary artery bypass or aortic valve
replacement, performed at the same time.
There were no operative mortalities in elective, isolated mitral valve repairs
and a low 30-day mortality rate of 2.5% (five patients). Patient improvement was
apparent using New York Heart Association (NYHA) classifications.
Postoperatively, 83.5% of patients were NYHA class I or II, compared with
preoperative classifications of III or IV for 96.0% of the patients.
Seven years after the surgery, 91.3% of patients were still alive. Only 7.9% of
patients needed additional operations and there was no late thromboembolism.
Success of mitral valve repair surgery is attributed to patient selection,
accurate evaluation of the cause of mitral regurgitation and the surgeon's
execution of the appropriate repair techniques, according to Lawrie.
In other news, TSA cardiovascular surgeons are teaching the operating room nurses
at Methodist Hospital the latest techniques in minimally invasive surgery, which
they recently studied in Pittsburgh.